A Safe Place to Fail
Why Masonry Matters
It is a fair question, and it is asked more often now than it once was. A fraternity centuries old, meeting in a building, on a set night, keeping forms that were old when our grandfathers learned them. In an age that can hand any man an audience before breakfast, what is the use of a room?
I think the question answers itself, though not the way the asker expects.
The Age of Connection
We live in the most connected era in human history. A man can reach the far side of the world in the time it takes to draw a breath. Without leaving his chair he can belong to a hundred communities, and at any hour of the night he will find a thousand voices that agree with him exactly.
And men have never been lonelier.
Something has gone quietly wrong. The pathways multiplied and the connection thinned. We built instruments of instant contact and found out that contact is not company. A man can be spoken to all day and go a week without anyone looking him in the eye. He can be surrounded by agreement and never once hear the truth from someone who loves him.
That is the ground the question of relevance should be argued on. The world has become very good at reaching men and very bad at gathering them.
An Analogue Place
Masonry offers something this age has nearly stopped producing. An analogue place.
A room. A night. Men in it, in person, with their coats on. No feed, no algorithm deciding who you hear from, no sorting of men into those who already think as you do. In the Lodge a man of one creed sits beside a man of another, and a tradesman beside a physician, and neither of them is asked to explain himself. The brother across from you may hold political views that are the opposite of yours. It will not come up, and after a few years you may still not know.
That is not an accident of who happened to join. It is the design. We do not debate religion or politics on the floor. To an outsider that sounds like avoidance. It is the very thing that makes the room possible, because it clears away the two subjects that sort men into camps and leaves the man himself.
Very few places in modern life still do that. It would be enough on its own to justify the Craft.
Is It Only a Fraternity?
The dictionary is plain enough. A fraternity is a body of people joined by a common purpose or interest. By that definition Masonry qualifies, and we call ourselves a fraternal order without embarrassment.
But the word carries a second meaning, and that is where I think we are misread. Say “fraternity” and many people hear “social club.” A place to gather, eat, laugh, and pass an evening among friends.
I will concede the point before it is made. Masonry is also that. There is food. There is laughter. Some of the finest evenings of my life have been spent at a table with brethren over a meal with nothing solemn about it. Any man who tells you the fellowship is incidental has not been paying attention.
Yet to call Masonry a social club is to see the temple as a stone building.
The stones are real. You can put your hand on them. They are also the least of what a temple is, and a man who describes one by its masonry has told you nothing about why anyone walks in.
A Building Ground
The Lodge is a building ground.
Men come into it unfinished, which is the only way anyone comes into anything. What they find is structure. Ritual first. It is older than any of us, we did not invent it, and we cannot amend it to suit ourselves. There is a particular humility in speaking words that thousands of men have spoken before you, in the same order, for the same purpose. It shows a man his place in a line that runs backward and forward well beyond his own lifetime.
They find counsel. A brother who sees another going wrong is charged to whisper good counsel, privately, kindly, before the error hardens. Not to correct him in public. Not to let it pass in silence either. That is a difficult and unfashionable duty, and I know of no other institution in a man’s life that formally asks it of him.
I have been on the receiving end of that duty for the whole of my journey. There have been brothers beside me at every step, men who mentored me without ever using the word. What I have come to admire in them is their timing. They knew when to simply listen and nod. They knew when to step into the conversation and correct my shortcomings. Those are two different gifts, and most men have neither. A friend who only listens is pleasant company. A friend who only corrects is a weight to carry. The man who can tell which one the moment calls for is rare, and the Craft has turned out a great many of them.
I will not name those brothers here, and that is rather the point. A correction given in private stays in private. Otherwise it was a performance, and every man on the receiving end can tell the difference.
A Safe Place to Fail
The Lodge gives a man something rarer than structure or counsel. Somewhere to fail.
Consider how little of that exists for a grown man. At work he is measured. In public he is recorded, and among strangers he is judged before he opens his mouth. Where is he allowed to stand up, attempt something hard, do it badly in front of other men, and be helped instead of mocked?
In the Lodge. That is where.
I do not offer this as theory. I have stood in that room with my legs shaking under me, addressing the brethren as my station demands, or carrying my part through one of our ceremonies, unsure whether my voice would hold. Not one man there was waiting for me to fail. They were waiting for me to finish, and that is an entirely different thing to stand in front of. A man cannot be told what that feels like. He has to be in the room.
And the men watching a brother struggle through his part are the ones who know exactly what it cost him. Every one of them has stood there.
The Craft does not ask a man to do it all at once. Here I think our forefathers were wiser than they are given credit for. The officer line is a ladder. Each station asks a little more than the one below it, so a man learns to stand and speak in a small way long before he is asked to do it in a large one. He fails incrementally, in front of men who once failed in that same chair, and he grows continually. By the time a heavy duty arrives he has already been prepared for it by every lighter one he carried.
That is the building ground. A man does not become better because someone told him to. He becomes better slowly, in a place built to allow it, in front of witnesses who want him to.
What Is a Better Man?
The phrase gets used so often it has gone soft. It is worth saying plainly what we mean by it.
We mean tenets. Not preferences, and not values in the modern sense, where a value is a thing a man holds until it becomes inconvenient. Every Mason binds himself to obligations. They are not negotiable, they were never written to be comfortable, and no rank exempts a man from them.
I will not recite them here. They are in print for any man who cares to look, and a list read off a page is the least of what they are.
What matters is that they are carried daily. A man takes them out of the Lodge with him and into his marriage, his work, his temper, and his handling of the people who can do nothing for him. That is the test, and it is administered every day without warning.
I will be honest about the standard. We do not meet it perfectly and no man does. We keep it fresh in mind, and where we fall short we make the utmost effort to close the distance. Failing to keep an obligation does not lighten it. We measure ourselves against it because it does not move.
A Lesson for Every Reader
You need not be a Mason to take something from this.
Every person alive needs at least one analogue place. Somewhere you are known by face rather than by profile, where the people present did not assemble because they agree with you. A place that lets you be bad at something in front of others while you learn to be good at it. And a friend there with the standing to tell you the truth in private, before your error becomes your reputation.
It may be a Lodge. It may be a congregation, a crew, a hālau, a game store. Find the room. Go to it in person. Keep going when it is inconvenient, because the whole value of the thing is on the far side of the inconvenience.
The Charge
So, is Masonry relevant today?
It is relevant so long as men still need to be gathered rather than merely reached. They still need structure they did not design for their own comfort, and somewhere safe to fail on the way to becoming what they intend to be.
That need has not diminished in this age. It has grown, and quietly, while we were all busy being connected.
The Craft did not change to meet this moment. It meets where it has always met, on the same night, doing the same work it has always done. What changed is how badly the world outside that room needs one like it.
If you are interested, come and visit us on Wednesday nights. We do not invite. We welcome.
Quick Links
Get In Touch
Or visit us every Wednesday from 6pm-9pm
Our Temple Address: 1227 Makiki Street Honolulu, HI 96814.
Mailing address: P.O. Box 22645, Honolulu, HI 96823.
© All Rights Reserved.